family guide
Who Decides When Mom Can’t? Power of Attorney, Health Care Surrogate, or Guardianship
How Florida powers of attorney, health care surrogates, and guardianship work, why an old power of attorney may not be enough, and what happens when there is no family to serve.
A hospital needs a signature to admit Mom to rehab. The bank will not discuss Dad’s account. A Medicaid caseworker asks who is authorized to apply. In each case the question is the same: who has the legal authority to act?
Being a spouse or adult child does not, by itself, give anyone that authority in Florida. It comes from documents the person signed while they still had capacity, or from a judge. Here is how each tool works and where each one falls short.
The three questions to ask first
- Did the parent sign planning documents while they had capacity? If so, the people named can usually act now.
- Do the documents cover what is needed? Money, health care, and Medicaid planning may each require specific language.
- Can and will the named people serve? A named agent who has died, moved away, or refuses to act leaves a gap.
Durable power of attorney: for money and property
A durable power of attorney lets a person (the principal) name an agent to handle financial and legal matters. It stays in effect if the principal later loses capacity. In Florida:
- Who can serve: the agent must be a person 18 or older, or a financial institution with trust powers that does business in Florida.
- How it is signed: the principal must sign in front of two witnesses and a notary.
- When it takes effect: a Florida power of attorney signed on or after October 1, 2011 is effective as soon as it is signed. “Springing” powers that take effect only upon incapacity are generally no longer valid for documents signed after that date.
- Special powers need special initials. Some powers, such as making gifts, creating or changing a trust, and changing beneficiary designations or survivorship rights, are valid only if the principal initialed or signed next to each one. These are often the powers needed for Medicaid planning.
- It ends at death. After death, the personal representative of the estate takes over.
Why an old power of attorney can fail. A form signed fifteen years ago may be a springing power that no longer works, may lack the gifting and trust powers that Medicaid planning requires, or may name an agent who has since died. Some banks also balk at older forms. Having a Florida attorney look it over now costs far less than discovering the problem in a hospital hallway.
Health care surrogate: for medical decisions
A health care surrogate designation names a person to make medical decisions if the principal cannot, or, if the document says so, while the principal still can. In Florida:
- It must be signed in front of two adult witnesses, and at least one may not be the principal’s spouse or blood relative.
- The surrogate can talk with doctors, review medical records, consent to or refuse treatment, and choose facilities.
- A living will is a separate document that states the person’s wishes about life-prolonging treatment at the end of life.
- A HIPAA authorization lets family members receive medical information even when no decision is needed.
If no surrogate was named, Florida law allows a health care proxy chosen in a set order: a court-appointed guardian, a spouse, a majority of adult children, a parent, an adult sibling, another adult relative, a close friend, and in some cases a clinical social worker. A proxy can make health care decisions only. A proxy cannot pay bills, sell property, or apply for Medicaid.
Other planning tools
- Pre-need guardian designation: a written statement naming who the person wants as guardian if one is ever needed. The court gives it strong weight.
- Revocable living trust: lets a successor trustee manage assets placed in the trust without court involvement.
- Joint accounts and payable-on-death designations: useful in limited cases, but they can create tax, creditor, and Medicaid problems if used without advice.
When guardianship becomes necessary
Guardianship is a court process in which a judge decides that a person lacks capacity to make some or all of their own decisions and appoints a guardian to act for them. It is usually needed when:
- The person never signed a power of attorney or health care surrogate designation and can no longer do so
- The documents do not cover what is needed, such as Medicaid planning or a move to a facility
- The named agent cannot or will not serve, or is misusing their authority
- The person is being exploited, neglected, or is refusing care in a way that puts them in danger
- Family members disagree and cannot reach a decision
How the Florida process works
- A petition to determine incapacity is filed with the circuit court.
- The court appoints an attorney for the person and an examining committee of three professionals, who each evaluate the person.
- A judge holds a hearing and decides whether the person is incapacitated, and in what areas.
- If so, the court appoints a guardian, either a limited guardian with only the powers the person needs or a plenary guardian with full authority.
- The guardian files an initial plan and inventory, then annual reports and accountings that the court reviews.
Florida law requires the court to consider whether less restrictive alternatives, such as existing documents or supported decision making, would meet the person’s needs. Guardianship is meant to be the last resort, not the first.
When there is no time for the full process, the court can name an emergency temporary guardian. Adults with developmental disabilities may be served instead by a guardian advocate, a simpler proceeding.
Guardian of the person and guardian of the property
Florida separates decisions about the person (housing, medical care, daily needs) from decisions about property (income, accounts, real estate, benefits). One guardian can hold both roles, or the court can split them. The two kinds of guardian are compared side by side in a separate article.
What happens when there is no family to serve?
More Floridians are outliving their spouses and siblings, or have children too far away or too ill to help. When no relative can serve, the court can turn to a registered professional guardian. For adults who cannot pay, public guardianship offices and nonprofit programs cover part of the need, though not all of it.
That gap is where AgedCare Guardian works. Its guardians are named individually in each case, answer to the Foundation, and accept cases for adults who have no means to pay.
See how its guardians work at AgedCare Guardian.
Before you call an attorney
- Find the parent’s power of attorney, health care surrogate, living will, and any pre-need guardian designation.
- Check the dates and confirm the named people can still serve.
- If the parent still has capacity, have a Florida attorney review or update the documents now.
- If the parent has lost capacity and no documents exist, talk with an attorney about guardianship or less restrictive alternatives.
- If there is no family able to serve, contact a professional guardian.
More in this guide
Part of When Mom or Dad Needs More Help.
- Is It Time for Professional Help? Home Care, Assisted Living, Nursing Home, or Guardianship
- Is Medicaid the Right Option? Florida Long-Term Care Medicaid Explained
- Protecting Income and Assets When Applying for Benefits in Florida
- Guardian of the Person vs. Guardian of the Property in Florida
- Emergency Temporary Guardianship in Florida: When You Can’t Wait
- How Guardianship Stops Elder Financial Exploitation
- How Florida Courts Supervise Guardians: Reports, Audits, and Your Rights
Other family guides: Fiduciary Services in Florida and Dementia, Aging, and the Law.
A summary of Florida law for general education. A Florida attorney can review your family’s own documents.
Unsure whether your parent’s documents still work? Send us a note and we will help you sort out next steps.
Be the someone for someone: when a person has no one left to name, the Foundation steps in. Your donation makes that possible for adults who cannot pay.


